Bad Behaviour and Viral Social Media
Brandon Sun, May 25, 2015 - David
At first, I was mystified. Some young male soccer fans in Toronto were shouting obscenities. Why is this national news? But, as I was to learn, such yelling is not an isolated incident. It is a real thing: spread by the Internet and acted out in the world at large.
Who knows how Internet memes get started? Apparently, something happened in a U.S. newscast that turned out to be a hoax. Whatever. When something goes viral, it becomes a trend, it creates its own power. So, for about a year now, men have been shouting obscenities into the microphones of women TV news reporters. That was what happened to Shauna Hunt of CityNews at the Toronto soccer game. But this time, she reacted.
“I hit my limit and I had to push back,” Hunt later said. “I wasn’t going to stand for it anymore.” Hunt confronted the heckler and his friends. The video of that confrontation went viral.
To expose this phenomenon has been good. I assume that most people – like me – had no idea this was happening. But it is widespread. A dozen CBC reporters and videographers in Winnipeg have since come out to say that they have been subjected to this abuse. Saskatchewan reporters say that they are insulted in towns and cities across the province. These journalists describe such experiences as “mortifying.”
The Brandon Sun reported in a Canadian Press story that the Toronto viral video had ignited “a social media firestorm.” One of the men in the video was identified as Shawn Simoes, an engineer with an electrical company, Hydro One.
Simoes got a lot more than his 15 minutes of fame. Simoes became one of the best known – and most reviled – people in the country. He even appeared in a newspaper political cartoon. And, though he was on his own time and not associated with his employer, he was fired from his $100,000-a-year job. Hydro One said in a statement that it terminated Simoes for violating the company’s code of conduct.
And the Internet continues to pile on. Mentioning Simoes and linking to the news stories are countless blog posts, Facebook uploads, and Twitter tweets. In the future, prospective employers doing an Internet search of Simoes will know about this incident. Simoes has become toxic. He may never work again.
The whole arc of this story is worth reflecting on. Viral videos are not only about cute kittens. Sometimes they can spread hate and abuse. Sometimes they can alert us to injustice.
I would like to add a cautionary note, however. I would like to see employers not just firing employees who are caught on video acting in embarrassing ways. Just as in the larger society, draconian punishments often don’t work out well.
(But we too often think that harsh punishment will smarten people up. Take the political cartoon of Simoes noted earlier. It approvingly shows his mother publicly humiliating him, calling him an “idiot,” and slapping him. Like, that’s how parents should teach respect?)
In cases like this, employers could consider “restorative justice.” That approach seeks to restore the situation to what it was before the wrongful behaviour. Restorative justice can be a better way to provide restitution, to comfort victims, and to reform offenders.
A young man acted rashly and rudely. But his employer missed the opportunity to demonstrate how to act calmly and politely. Because now that young man has lost his job as well. If he can never work again, he won’t be the only one to suffer. We all will, with the expense of lost productivity, welfare, or even jail.
How better to deal with such a situation? Perhaps a short work suspension, an apology, a requirement to attend or even help create a harassment prevention workshop? Out of one stupid mistake, there could be a chance to build long-term empathy and maturity.
The Internet invites us to learn about all sorts of things. The Internet also invites us to imitate behaviour – good and bad. And the Internet invites us to jump to easy conclusions, to seek instant gratification, and to shame others.
Whether on the Internet – or in the real world – let’s try to remember to resist our worst impulses.
Empathy Key to Preventing Bullying
The Medium is the Message?
Perception and Reality of Crime Not Always the Same
Surfing World Wide Web Breeds Shallow Thinking
Send me an email
My Sites / Interests
- Je Suis Charlie
- Citizen Active
- The Great War
- Live Well, Do Good
- Manitoba History
- Obituary Guide
- The War on Drugs
Some Reviewed Books:
The War on Drugs:
A Failed Experiment
Why Islam Needs a Reformation Now
Islam and the Future of Tolerance:
The Greatest Show on Earth:
The Evidence for Evolution